For over 30 years...

Bagels Your Way Cafe has served our local community.

Established in 1978, as one of the first "Bagel Cafes" on Long Island. Bagels Your Way Cafe is the NY bagel cafe benchmark. Setting the standard with a family secret recipe only found here.


Open Daily at 5am, We serve breakfast & lunch (eggs too) all day.


As we did over 25 years ago,

Our traditions of quality & presentation hold strong.



Rainbow Crazy Bagels
Quick Links


E mail Your Order

Catering Information

Helping Our Community

Shipping Bagels

Contact us


Clean & Current Sit Down Cafe

Call In / Takeout 


Great Food

Friendly Service

Huge Selection

Free Wifi

Bigscreen TV

Satellite Radio

ATM access

Breakfast & Lunch Catering

Gift Cards 

Credit/ Debit cards accepted

Gluten Free Options

Vegan & Low Sodium Options

What Makes us Better?